top of page

Seller Hack: How To Price Your Key West Home When New Listings Surge

Writer: Krystal Sheehan
Krystal Sheehan
12 minutes ago
4 min read
Woman in a car, wearing mirrored sunglasses and a colorful shirt, flashing a peace sign in bright sunlight.
Key West & Florida Keys Realtor Krystal Sheehan. Broker Associate @ eXp Realty & Founder of The Good Company Agent Organization


Key Takeaways

  • New Key West listings outpaced new pendings 25 to 3 in the November 2 to 9 window.

  • In October 2026, the 33040 median sale price was $1,059,000 while the median active list price was $1,194,000.

  • Homes that sold had typically reduced: median 93.2% of original list price.

  • Florida sellers must give buyers a flood disclosure at or before signing the contract.


How should I price my Key West home this season?


Start with closed sales from the last few months for homes like yours, then adjust for condition, elevation, parking, outdoor space and rental license status. The trap this season is pricing to the listing down the street. According to Florida Keys MLS data, the October 2026 median active list price in 33040 was $1,194,000, while the median sale price was $1,059,000. That gap is roughly what buyers have been unwilling to pay.


Key West also had about 8.3 months of supply as of November 9, 2026, up from 7.8 the week before. With 286 active homes, buyers can compare, and they do. The listings that sell first are the ones that look like the best value on day one.


Does overpricing really cost Key West sellers money?


Yes, and likely in more ways than you anticipated.


Homes that closed November 3 to 9 sold at a median 96.0% of their final list price, but 93.2% of their original list price. So for example, that means if a property was listed for $1,000,000 it sold for $932,000.


Key West listings averaged 135 days on market (median 89) as of November 9. Every month on market adds carrying costs: insurance, taxes, utilities and maintenance.


And it's also costing you from a time value of money perspective. Where else could you be investing your proceeds to generate income and what is that costing you. Let's use that million dollar home example and say that the sellers owe $650K so they will net $350K from the sale of their home.


$350K invested at 6% return is $1,750 per month in interest. So in this example, for every month that your home sits you lose $1,750 in addition to your carrying costs and that can compound very quickly.


Meanwhile, standout homes priced right are still selling quickly and close to asking.

Pricing approach

What buyers see

Typical result

Priced to closed comps

A fair value next to new listings

Showings early, stronger offers

Priced to active listings

One of many similar options

Longer market time

Priced above the market

A home to watch, not buy

Price cuts, offers below original list

What flood disclosure do Florida sellers have to give?


Since October 1, 2024, Florida law requires sellers of residential property to complete a flood disclosure. Under section 689.302, Florida Statutes, it must be delivered "at or before the time the sales contract is executed." It asks whether the seller knows of flooding that damaged the property during their ownership, whether they filed a flood damage claim (including with the National Flood Insurance Program), and whether they received flood damage assistance, including from FEMA, as reported by WUSF.


Gather your flood history, elevation certificate and current insurance declarations before you list. Buyers in the Keys ask about insurance in the first showing, and having answers ready builds trust. My Insurance and Flood guides explain what buyers will look for.


What helps a Key West listing stand out right now?


Presentation, documentation and price, in that order of buyer impression and reverse order of importance. Professional photos, a pre-listing inspection, permit history and current insurance quotes reduce buyer uncertainty. If the home has a transient rental license, document it clearly. If it is in the historic district, have any HARC approvals and permits organized; my Permits, HARC and ROGO posts explain why buyers ask.


What should I do before pricing my Key West home?


Before pricing your Key West home, walk through it the way a buyer will. Fix the small items an inspector will flag, clear clutter and make sure every permit is closed. Pull together your utility costs, insurance premiums and any association information, because Keys buyers budget carefully. Then ask your Realtor for a comparative market analysis built on closed sales, with notes on how your home differs from each one.


Timing matters too. Season visitors are here now, and the homes they see first get the most attention. Pricing your Key West home correctly on day one usually beats a series of reductions later, because the 25 new listings that arrived in a single week in early November gave buyers plenty to compare. If you are not sure whether to sell now or wait, run both scenarios with real carrying costs before you decide.


Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know what my Key West home is worth?

Start with recent closed sales of similar homes nearby, adjusted for condition, elevation, parking and license status. A local Realtor can pull these from the MLS.

As of November 9, 2026, active Key West listings averaged 135 days on market with a median of 89, according to Florida Keys MLS data.

Yes. Section 689.302, Florida Statutes requires a flood disclosure at or before contract signing for residential sales.

Season is already underway and buyers are visiting now. The bigger factor is pricing correctly against current competition.

Let's Talk About Your Next Move

Want to talk through your own situation? Call or text me at 305-394-4073, email krystal@kskeywest.com, or read more local guides at kskeywest.com/key-west-blog.

Sources

All The Best From The Florida Keys.

Krystal Sheehan · Broker Associate · eXp Realty · Licensed in Florida


This article is general information, not legal, tax, insurance or lending advice. Figures are as of the dates noted and can change; MLS figures are from the Florida Keys MLS via FlexMLS and are deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Verify details with the appropriate professional before making decisions.

Comments


bottom of page